MSLF Client Dies, Still Waiting for Justice

A man I deeply respected died last month.

Sidney Longwell, a devoted family man and entrepreneur in the finest tradition of the American Frontier, passed away last month at age 81. A fighter to the last, he died after 38 years of waiting for justice in his lawsuit against the federal government.

It is hard to comprehend the brute force of the federal government until it has been turned against you, personally, as it had been against Sidney. As an attorney for people like him, I see that force being used against good men and women every day.

Federal agencies have practically limitless resources to fight court battles, in terms of both money and manpower. They have no competition, no share- holders to placate, and no one person who can be held personally responsible for their malfeasance.

They also have the cruelest weapon of all — time.

Sidney’s daughter, Kelly Longwell, MSLF attorney David McDonald, and Sidney Longwell’s business partner, Sonny Cranch

In Sidney’s case, he purchased a Montana oil and gas lease from the federal government in 1982, passed a decade of rigorous environmental and archaeological reviews, and was all set to develop the land when the government suspended his lease in 1993. He spent 38 years fighting a David-and-Goliath battle to use the leased mineral rights — a battle I’m still fighting as an attorney for his family.

Sidney’s passing reminds me that time really is the most devastating weapon the government has in its arsenal. We can give our clients resources, expertise, and a team of people to fight on their behalf, but sometimes they can’t outlast Uncle Sam.

Despite obtaining drilling approvals four separate times after proving that environmental and tribal cultural concerns were unfounded, federal agencies refused to act, keeping Sidney stuck in bureaucratic purgatory.

Ronald Reagan was in his first term when Sidney’s struggle began — think about that.

A favorable court ruling in 2016 seemed to promise a resolution. But, given 21 days to come up with a schedule to act, the government dug in its heels instead, abruptly cancelling the lease. Incredibly, the government’s lawyers justified the decision by inventing a procedural defect that contradicted what agency officials had told Sidney for 30 years. We are still appealing on behalf of the family Sidney left behind.

The federal government strung Sidney along for decades, content to let him spend his golden years waiting for a decision that would never come. After all that waiting, instead of justice, bureaucrats gave him another slap in the face.

More than ever, Americans are being governed, not by laws, but by regulations. These regulations are created and enforced by countless unelected and unaccountable officials who staff government agencies. There is a terrible cost that comes with delegating so much power to this permanent bureaucracy to control our lives. If agency officials wish to prevent you from doing something, they can probably find a way to tie you up in red tape for as long as it takes, knowing you will never be able to outspend or outlast the federal government.

We must hold government agencies accountable when they abuse their power. Applying for a permit, as Sidney did, and spending decades fighting in court for the right to use it, should not be the legacy inherited from a dying parent.

MSLF attorney David McDonald represents the Longwell family in the case Solenex LLC v. Bernhardt, currently before the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.

(This article was adapted from an op-ed published in The Federalist.)

Sidney Longwell’s case is a story of egregious behavior by the federal government.
Explore this case

Solenex, LLC v. Bernhardt

View Case
Explore More

Video: A 37 Year Fight to Use Leased Lands

Imagine buying a lease from the government, spending years following the rules and preparing to access leased minerals, only to have it cancelled and have to sue for your rights? Sidney Longwell doesn’t have to imagine. He’s living it.

Join the Fight

Since 1977, MSLF has fought to protect private property rights, individual liberties, and economic freedom. MSLF is a nonprofit public interest legal foundation. We represent clients pro bono and receive no government funding. Make your 100% tax deductible contribution today and join the fight.

Donate Now

News Updates