The Supreme Merit of Amy Coney Barrett

News Flash: Trump’s Supreme Court pick, Amy Coney Barrett, is a woman. And a mother of seven. And a Catholic.

But none of those things are what really matters. Just like you, at MSLF, we would never interview a job applicant based on the factors above. While nothing should be ignored when vetting someone for a position this important, here at Mountain States, we abhor identity politics. We still believe that merit is the most important factor in hiring decisions.

Amy Coney Barrett has spent her professional life demonstrating her merit. She graduated first in her class at Notre Dame law school, where she later taught. After law school, she clerked for Justice Antonin Scalia. Professor Robert P. George of Princeton University, one of our nation’s leading conservative intellectuals, praised Barrett with these words: “On character, temperament, and intellect she is the top of the top—of any group.”

But what excites us the most is that she has a demonstrated record as a constitutional jurist. She interprets the text but only the text. She recognizes it isn’t her job to invent laws from the bench. It is her job to simply interpret the laws our elected representatives have written.

Thus, although she is a woman, and the mother of seven, and a faithful Catholic—all admirable traits—it is her record as a judge and scholar that makes her worthy of the bench. At MSLF we don’t care what your race, creed, color—or in this case, gender—is. We care that you respect the Constitution. She does. That’s why Amy Coney Barrett is where she belongs—on the Supreme Court.

Explore More

Check-The-Box “Diversity” is At Odds with a Merit-Based Society

When did merit cease to serve as the primary basis for political or professional advancement in this supposedly colorblind, “gender-neutral,” equality-oriented society?  I of course recognize “diversity” (however one defines it) as a worthy goal, broadly speaking. But it amazes and troubles me to see “diversity” totally eclipsing all other considerations in so many aspects of contemporary life.   We saw this most recently in the confirmation hearings for Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court.…

My MSLF Fellowship Was Time Well-Spent

Liberty can only ever be as strong as its most avid defender. When I applied to Mountain States Legal Foundation, I wanted to join a group engaged in the defense of liberty; and when I arrived, Mountain States Legal Foundation placed me on the front lines. I worked to stop administrative agency overreach and abuse,…

Why Donor Privacy Must Be Protected

A case now before the Supreme Court could profoundly impact the future success or failure of the liberty movement. Although it’s not a case we are a party to, we will file a brief supporting our friends at Americans for Prosperity and we’re closely watching the case on behalf of our privacy-minded donors. In the…

Let The Sun Shine In

Who possibly benefits by keeping regulatory science operating in the shadows? What do the data-deniers have to fear from full disclosure if the “regulatory science” is sound?

Join the Fight

Since 1977, MSLF has fought to protect private property rights, individual liberties, and economic freedom. MSLF is a nonprofit public interest legal foundation. We represent clients pro bono and receive no government funding. Make your 100% tax deductible contribution today and join the fight.

Donate Now

News Updates