Another ESA Success Evokes Howls of Protest from Wolf Recovery Deniers

Instead of applauding yet another success of the Endangered Species Act in providing for the recovery of the previously threatened Gray Wolf population in the lower-48 states, many environmental organizations and tribes are decrying the delisting of the species.

On Thursday, U.S. Interior Secretary David Bernhardt announced the delisting of the species, calling it a remarkable comeback story that had achieved all established recovery goals.  But this story is far from over.

Environmental organizations have already announced that they will challenge the rule in court, despite the fact that the rule has yet to be formally published in the federal register.

“Mountain States Legal Foundation will always advocate to uphold the original intent of the Endangered Species Act, which requires the federal government return management of a species back to the states when that species meets all objective recovery criteria,” said Cody J. Wisniewski, an attorney with Mountain States Legal Foundation. “The gray wolf is no different.”

The ESA, enacted in 1973, was seemingly a well-intentioned piece of legislation.  It sought to allow the federal government to aid states with the recovery of endangered and threatened species within a state’s jurisdiction, and then to return full management of that species back to the state upon recovery.

But after nearly 50 years of litigation and legal precedent, the ESA is now used by environmental organizations and tribes to lock up large swaths of federally managed lands, preventing agricultural and resource use and development.

“Allowing states to decide how to manage the gray wolf populations in their borders allows the state to tailor management to the needs of the people that actually live and work in these areas,” added Wisniewski.  “Local officials are better able to assess the needs of their residents and respond to their concerns than the federal government when it comes to wolf management.”

The aggressive penalties for a “take” of a listed species, even an apex predator like the gray wolf, are so severe that ranchers and farmers are often afraid to defend their own lives for fear of being prosecuted by the federal government.  These penalties also prevent agricultural operations and natural resource development from being able to engage in many activities on federally managed lands because of their inability to “disturb” the habitat or the species.  Listed species can pose massive roadblocks to development of the United States’ valuable resources or the raising and growing of our own food.

Mountain States Legal Foundation has a history of defending delistings and advocating for state-level management of recovered species and will continue to fight to ensure that the federal government maintains an appropriately limited role when addressing those species—including the gray wolf.

Explore More

New Case Alert: Grizzly Fight Becomes Environmentalist Power Grab

Scientists say the Yellowstone Area Grizzly has recovered and should no longer be listed on the Endangered Species List. It was a conservation success. Instead of rejoicing, big-city environmentalists sued to keep the bear on the endangered list. Now, in a new lawsuit, the radical groups are using the grizzly again to advance their anti-ranching agenda.

Supreme Court Halts NYC’s Flight from Review under Second Amendment

This case arose as a result of NYC’s unconstitutional ban on transporting a licensed handgun outside city limits. For the past six years, NYC has vehemently defended its handgun transportation ban, but only at the last minute sought to avoid Supreme Court review when city officials realized the odds of success weren’t in their favor.

The Perversion of the Endangered Species Act

MSLF attorney Cody Wisniewski published an article today in RealClearPolicy, explaining how the Endangered Species Act has been abused in order to lock up enormous tracts of land under federal control: No good deed goes unpunished. Similarly, it seems no well-intentioned piece of legislation is ever used as intended. This could not be more true…

Join the Fight

Since 1977, MSLF has fought to protect private property rights, individual liberties, and economic freedom. MSLF is a nonprofit public interest legal foundation. We represent clients pro bono and receive no government funding. Make your 100% tax deductible contribution today and join the fight.

Donate Now

News Updates